Login Menu

Does public liability insurance cover employees?

FacebookTwitterPinterestWhatsappEmail
A small UK cafe owner in an orange apron briefing two staff members behind the counter while a customer is served

No. Public liability pays out when a customer, visitor or another business claims against you, but it does not cover claims from your own staff. The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) says it covers members of the public and other businesses, “but not for claims by employees” (HSE guide HSE40).

Staff injuries and work-related illness fall under employers’ liability. GOV.UK says you must have it as soon as you become an employer, with cover of at least £5 million from an authorised insurer (GOV.UK).

Why doesn’t public liability cover your staff?

Because the two policies are built around who makes the claim. Public liability is for people outside your business. Employers’ liability is for people who work for you, and the law treats it as a separate, compulsory cover.

HSE describes public liability as generally voluntary and employers’ liability as compulsory (HSE40). So holding a generous public liability limit does nothing to meet your legal duty once you take someone on. Our public liability insurance page explains limits and what that cover pays for.

Which policy deals with which claim?

The answer depends on who was hurt and whether they were working for you at the time. Here is how the most common cases usually split. Policy wordings differ, so check yours or ask the insurer about anything unusual.

Who is hurt or has a lossUsually dealt with underWhy
A customer, visitor or passer-byPublic liabilityThey are members of the public
A client whose property you damagePublic liabilityThird-party property damage
Your employee, injured while workingEmployers’ liabilityInjury arising out of their employment
A former employee with an illness from past workEmployers’ liabilityHSE says former employees can claim too
A volunteer, unpaid student or work experience pupilUsually employers’ liabilityHSE says insurers usually include them; check
A labour-only helper you direct and equipMay need employers’ liabilityThe control tests can make them an employee
A subcontractor running their own businessTheir own public liabilityThey are not your employee
An employee hurt in a road accident while workingPossibly your motor policyHSE says motor cover may deal with it
You, as a sole trader with no staffNeitherLiability cover pays claims against you, not your own injury

Who counts as an employee for employers’ liability?

Anyone you take on under a contract of service or apprenticeship, whatever you call them. HSE says “It does not matter whether you usually call someone an employee or self-employed or what their tax status is.” What matters is the real relationship and how much control you have over their work (HSE40).

HSE lists signs that someone may need to be covered as your employee:

  • you deduct income tax and National Insurance from their pay
  • you control where, when and how they work
  • you supply their materials and equipment
  • they cannot send a substitute if they are unable to work
  • they do the same work, on the same terms, as your other staff

GOV.UK’s own tests point the same way. Someone is probably self-employed if they quote for work, send invoices, work without direct supervision and pay their own tax and National Insurance (GOV.UK). Signs of an employee include set hours, paid holiday and a manager deciding how the work is done (GOV.UK).

When don’t you need employers’ liability at all?

Only in a few cases. GOV.UK says you do not need it if you only employ close family members, or only employ people based outside England, Scotland and Wales (GOV.UK).

HSE adds two details. The family exemption does not apply to a family business set up as a limited company. And a company whose only employee is its owner, holding 50% or more of the shares, is exempt (HSE40). If you are unsure whether an exemption fits, ask the insurer before you rely on it.

Worked example: one café, two claims

Amira runs a small café in Leeds with two part-time staff. On a busy Saturday a customer slips on a freshly mopped floor and hurts her wrist. Later that day, Amira’s barista burns his hand on the steam wand.

The customer’s claim goes to Amira’s public liability insurer, because she is a member of the public. The barista’s claim goes to the employers’ liability insurer, because he was hurt doing his job. If Amira only held public liability, the second claim would have no policy behind it.

Worked example: the decorator’s helper

Dan is a self-employed decorator. For a three-week job he brings in a helper, Josh, who uses Dan’s brushes and ladders and works the hours Dan sets. Josh cannot send anyone in his place.

On HSE’s tests, Josh looks like an employee, even though Dan pays him cash per day. Dan should tell his insurer and ask whether he needs employers’ liability. Our tradesman insurance page shows how trades usually combine the two covers.

What happens if you only have public liability and a member of staff is hurt?

Your business would face the claim without the compulsory cover in place, and you could be fined. GOV.UK says you can be fined £2,500 for every day you are not properly insured (GOV.UK).

You must also display the certificate where staff can see it, which can be online, and show it to inspectors. Failing to do either can lead to a fine of up to £1,000 (HSE40).

Checklist before you take on your first worker

  • Work out their status using the GOV.UK employee and self-employed tests
  • Arrange employers’ liability from an authorised insurer before day one, with at least £5 million of cover
  • Tell the insurer about volunteers, students or helpers, especially for long placements or unusual work
  • Ask subcontractors for their own public liability certificate before they start
  • Check your motor policy covers staff who drive for work
  • Put the certificate where staff can read it, on paper or online
  • Keep old certificates: HSE says some diseases appear decades after exposure (HSE40)

Is employers’ liability included in public liability insurance?

Not automatically. They are separate covers, although many business policies include both sections. Check your schedule shows employers’ liability with a limit of at least £5 million, and that you have the certificate.

Does public liability cover subcontractors?

It depends on how much control you have over them. HSE says someone who supplies most of their own equipment, works for other clients and can send a substitute is unlikely to need your employers’ liability. A labour-only worker who uses your tools and works the hours you set may count as your employee. For genuine subcontractors, ask for their public liability certificate before they start. Check its limit meets what your contract or client asks for.

Does public liability cover me if I get hurt at work?

No. Public liability pays claims that others make against you, so it does not pay for your own injury as a sole trader. Some people look at personal accident or income cover for that risk.

Do I need employers’ liability for one part-time worker?

Yes, unless an exemption applies. GOV.UK says the duty starts as soon as you become an employer, and part-time staff are not among the exemptions it lists.

Are volunteers covered by public liability or employers’ liability?

HSE says insurers usually include volunteers, unpaid students and work experience pupils under an existing employers’ liability policy. Talk to the insurer for long placements, unusual work, or if you hold no employers’ liability yet.

Is a family business exempt from employers’ liability?

It depends on how the business is set up. HSE says the close-relative exemption does not apply to a family business incorporated as a limited company. If the business is not a limited company and everyone you employ is a close relative, such as a wife, son or sister, GOV.UK says you do not need it.

Does employers’ liability cover staff injured away from my premises?

Generally yes. HSE says employers’ liability covers work-related injury or illness on or off site. Injuries from road accidents while working may be covered by your motor insurance instead.

What if a member of staff is hurt while visiting as a customer?

Employers’ liability covers injury arising out of their work for you. If they were off duty and shopping, the claim may sit with public liability instead. Ask your insurer how the wording treats it.

What to do next

If you have anyone working for you, quote for both covers together. Tiger.co.uk lets you compare employers’ liability quotes from UK providers with one short form. Ask each provider whether they can bundle both sections into a single business policy. You can also start a business insurance quote on Tiger.co.uk.

Cover and prices vary, so read the policy wording before you buy. See employers’ liability cover for exemptions and limits, and professional indemnity if clients rely on your expertise. Look at van insurance if staff drive for work, or the business insurance hub for every other cover.

Fact-checked by Ian Wilson, Managing Director at Tiger.co.uk. 20+ years in price comparison; MEng, Queen’s University Belfast.

Click to access the login or register cheese