Is contents insurance worth it?
For many households, yes, if a fire, flood or burglary could take things you could not replace from savings. In that case cover protects you from a bill you could not meet. It is your choice: GOV.UK’s How to buy guide for England and Wales says only that new owners should consider it.
It is worth less if you own very little, or if your most valuable things are already insured elsewhere. The quickest way to decide is to work out what replacing your belongings would cost.
Do you have to have contents insurance?
No. It is your choice whether you own or rent. GOV.UK’s guide for England and Wales says buildings cover is normally a requirement of a mortgage. Contents cover is something you “should also consider” (GOV.UK How to buy).
Scotland adds one legal duty, and it is about the building. Owners of tenement flats must insure their flat for its reinstatement value under section 18 of the Tenements (Scotland) Act 2004. That duty does not extend to your belongings. Wherever you live in the UK, check your own mortgage offer for any lender conditions.
How does the replacement test work?
Compare two numbers: the price of buying all your belongings again new, and what you could afford to pay if it all went at once. If the first is much bigger than the second, cover protects you from a cost you could not absorb if you need to claim.
Our contents cover page explains how to value your belongings room by room.
A few other factors push the answer one way or the other:
| Decision factor | Leans towards buying cover | Leans away from cover |
|---|---|---|
| Cost to replace vs your savings | Replacing everything would cost more than you could pay at once | You could replace it all from savings without real hardship |
| Your excess vs a likely claim | A typical loss, such as a ruined sofa and bed, would be well above the excess | Most things you own are worth little more than the excess |
| Items insured elsewhere | Your laptop, phone and bike are not on any other policy | Your most valuable items already have their own cover and you own little else |
| Furnished or unfurnished let | Unfurnished, so the bed, sofa and white goods are yours to replace | Fully furnished, so the big items belong to the landlord |
| Someone else’s policy | You live alone, or no one else’s policy includes your things | You live with parents or a partner whose policy may already include your belongings |
What does a contents policy pay for that people forget?
It covers more than burglary. The Association of British Insurers lists fire, storm, flood, burst pipes and theft among the usual risks a home policy covers (ABI home insurance guide).
The same guide says home insurance usually covers some of your personal legal liabilities, for example if a visitor is injured and you are found liable.
Some policies also include, or offer as extras, accidental damage and cover for belongings you take out of the home. These vary between policies, so check the schedule rather than assuming.
When might contents insurance not be worth it?
It can be poor value when the most you could ever claim is close to the excess. If your belongings would cost a few hundred pounds to replace, a large excess leaves little to claim.
It can also be poor value if your phone, laptop or bike is already on its own policy, such as gadget insurance or bicycle insurance. Work out what is left once those are taken out. If it is a few clothes and some second-hand furniture, you may prefer to carry the risk yourself.
If you do buy cover, pick an excess you could actually find the money for at short notice.
What if you rent your home?
If you own the things in your home, it is worth thinking about. The Financial Ombudsman Service notes that people who rent a property will only need to buy contents insurance.
How much it is worth depends on what you brought with you. In an unfurnished flat you own the bed, sofa and white goods, so the bill to replace them is larger. Our tenants contents insurance page covers renters’ policies, and students can look at student contents insurance.
How do you make sure a claim is paid in full?
Insure for the full cost of replacing everything, because some policies have an “average clause”. The Financial Ombudsman Service explains that this means you pay a proportion of the replacement cost if you are underinsured (FOS underinsurance guidance).
For help working out the figure itself, see our page on contents cover. The ombudsman’s complaints point to two traps when you buy:
- Check any part of an online form that is filled in for you. The ombudsman sees complaints where people were not told to check pre-filled parts of a form.
- Answer the question the insurer is really asking. The ombudsman says a form asking how much cover you need may really want the total value of everything in your home.
It also makes sense to look at the sum insured again after a big purchase, a wedding or Christmas.
A worked example: Jo, a renter in Cardiff
Jo rents an unfurnished one-bed flat in Cardiff. She owns a sofa, a bed, a desk, her own laptop, clothes, a bike and an engagement ring. She assumes it is all worth “not much” and nearly skips cover.
Going room by room, she finds the cost to replace it all new is far more than her savings. She buys a contents policy, checks the bike limit and lists her engagement ring separately.
Months later a pipe bursts in the flat above while she is away. Water ruins her sofa, mattress and rug. The landlord’s insurer deals with the ceiling. Jo claims for her own things on her contents policy and pays her excess.
Checklist: should you buy cover?
- Have you totalled the price of buying all your belongings again new?
- Could you pay that from savings if it all went at once?
- Are your most valuable items already insured on another policy?
- Do you own the furniture and appliances, or does the landlord?
- Would the excess leave anything worth claiming for?
- Does a parent’s or partner’s policy already include your things?
If you answer “no” to the second question, cover is likely to be worth comparing. For how prices are worked out, see our page on what home insurance costs.
Your questions answered
How do I decide if I need contents insurance?
Total the price of buying all your belongings again new, then ask whether you could pay that from savings. If you could not, cover is usually worth comparing. If you could, it may not be.
Does buildings insurance cover my belongings?
Generally not. The Financial Ombudsman Service says items you could reasonably remove and take to another home are usually contents. A buildings policy won’t generally pay for them. You can buy buildings-only cover, so check your schedule to see whether contents are included.
What if you share a flat with others?
Count only your own belongings when you do the replacement test. Your flatmates’ things are theirs to insure. If you bought something together, such as a TV, agree who lists it. Policies vary, so ask each insurer whose belongings it covers before you buy.
Do I need my own contents cover if I live with my parents?
Often not as a separate policy. Your parents’ home insurance may already include the belongings of family members living with them. Ask them to check the policy wording, especially for expensive items such as a laptop or bike.
Is cover still worth having if I own very little?
It may not be. If replacing everything would cost little more than the policy excess, a claim would pay out very little. Add up the full cost of replacing everything as new before you decide.
Do students need their own contents policy?
It depends on what you take with you. A parent’s home policy may extend to some of your things while you are away at university, so ask them to check that first. If not, add up your laptop, phone, bike and clothes.
Are old belongings worth insuring?
It can be. Some policies pay for new items rather than the second-hand value, so check the wording on each quote. Policies do not usually pay for things wearing out: the ABI lists wear and tear and poor maintenance as usual exclusions.
What happens if I underestimate the value of my contents?
If your policy has an average clause, the insurer may pay only a share of the claim. The Financial Ombudsman Service says this means you pay a proportion of the replacement cost if you are underinsured.
What to do next
Add up what you own and decide how much of that risk you could carry yourself. If cover makes sense, Tiger.co.uk lets you compare quotes for contents cover through one short form.
Policies vary, so check the excess, single item limit and exclusions on each quote. If you also own the building, our guide to buildings versus home insurance explains how the two parts fit together. The Tiger.co.uk home insurance hub covers the other options.
Fact-checked by Ian Wilson, Managing Director at Tiger.co.uk. 20+ years in price comparison; MEng, Queen’s University Belfast.