Why has my car insurance gone up?
Most car insurance rises come down to two things: insurers paying more to settle claims, or a change in your own details. The average premium paid was £562 in July to September 2026. That is £11 (2%) more than a year earlier, though £4 less than the previous quarter (Association of British Insurers, November 2026).
Has car insurance gone up in 2026?
Only slightly, and prices are still below their 2024 peak. After allowing for inflation, the July to September 2026 average was £7 lower than a year before, according to the same ABI figures.
The government’s Motor Insurance Taskforce final report, December 2025 sets out how prices moved before that:
| Period | Average premium paid | Where the figure comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Jan to Mar 2024 | £635 (comprehensive cover) | ABI, quoted in the Taskforce report as the peak |
| Jul to Sep 2025 | £551 | ABI, quoted in the Taskforce report |
| Apr to Jun 2026 | £566 | ABI, November 2026 (£4 above the Q3 figure) |
| Jul to Sep 2026 | £562 | ABI, November 2026 |
Why is car insurance so expensive in the UK?
The main reason is the cost of claims. Motor insurers paid out £3.2 billion in July to September 2026, matching the record set the quarter before and 8% more than a year earlier (ABI, November 2026).
The FCA looked at why premiums rose between 2019 and 2023. It found premiums rose mainly because claims costs outside insurers’ control went up, not because of profit. Across the 12 firms it studied, claims costs grew from £6.8 billion in 2019 to £9.1 billion in 2023. The main pressures it found are below, as reported in the Taskforce report.
| Cost pressure | What the evidence shows |
|---|---|
| Repairs | More complex cars, parts delays and a shortage of skilled labour. Waits before repairs start doubled, and repair times rose 36%. |
| Replacement cars | Spending on hire cars while yours is fixed rose by almost 50%, from £473 million to £699 million (2019 to 2023). |
| Injury claims | Around a third of all motor claims costs, up 7% between 2019 and 2023. |
| Uninsured drivers | Claims costs involving uninsured drivers rose by around 37% between 2019 and 2024. Insurers fund these payouts through a levy. |
| Car theft | Rising thefts were one of the drivers the FCA named. The Crime and Policing Act 2026 creates offences for electronic devices used to steal vehicles. These offences had not been brought into force when we checked in November 2026 (legislation.gov.uk). |
| Tax | Insurance Premium Tax is added at the standard rate of 12% (HMRC). |
Can your renewal rise if you have not claimed?
Insurers work out a fresh price at every renewal, so a clean year does not freeze your price.
Under FCA rules, a renewal quote cannot top the price for a matching new customer who buys by the same route, such as one website (FCA PS21/5). Our car insurance page explains how this works.
An incident you reported without claiming can also count. The Financial Ombudsman says any incident, however minor, can tell an insurer you are more likely to claim, so premiums may rise. A protected no claims discount does not fix the price either (Financial Ombudsman Service).
Why is my car insurance so high compared with other drivers?
Your price reflects how likely you are to claim and what a claim might cost, so personal details carry a lot of weight. Check whether any of these changed since last year:
| What changed | Why the price may rise | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| You moved home | Claims and theft rates differ by postcode | Your address and where you park at night |
| You changed car | Repair costs, theft risk and insurance group vary by model | Price the specific model before buying |
| Points or a conviction | Insurers see a higher chance of a claim | In Great Britain, endorsements last 4 or 11 years from the offence or conviction |
| A new driver on the policy | Less experienced drivers add risk | Who uses the car the most |
| Extras or a lower excess | More cover costs more | Whether you still need each add-on |
| Mileage or use | More miles bring more chances of an accident | An honest estimate, including commuting |
The endorsement rule comes from GOV.UK, which notes that Northern Ireland uses different endorsement processes. Adding a driver? Our named driver guide sets out how it works. Our young driver car insurance page covers why newer drivers pay more.
Worked example: a higher renewal with no claims
Gareth, 52, lives in Swansea and has not claimed for years. His renewal letter quoted noticeably more than he paid last year.
Going through the details, he found two changes. He had added his son, who passed his test in the spring, as a named driver. He had also reported a car park scrape to his insurer without claiming.
He confirmed his son’s details were right and kept him on, as he drives the car now and then. He then lined up quotes on identical cover and excess, and each insurer weighed the new driver and the incident differently. If his son starts using the car most, a black box policy in his own name may be worth pricing.
Will car insurance prices come down?
Nobody can say for certain, because prices follow claims costs, which the ABI says remain high.
The government’s Motor Insurance Taskforce finished its work in December 2025. It set out actions aimed at stabilising and reducing premiums, including on vehicle theft, repairs and claims processes. In England and Wales, the personal injury discount rate rose from -0.25% to 0.5% from 11 January 2025 (Ministry of Justice). Scotland and Northern Ireland moved to 0.5% in September 2024, so one rate now applies UK-wide (Motor Insurance Taskforce final report, December 2025). The Ministry of Justice estimated the change would save the insurance sector roughly £150 million a year, according to the Taskforce report.
How can you check a higher renewal price?
Check your details first, then get prices from other insurers for the same cover:
- Put last year’s price and this year’s side by side.
- Check every detail, from address and job title to drivers, mileage and convictions.
- Ask your insurer what has changed, especially if you reported an incident.
- Go through optional extras and the excess, and keep only what you need.
- Line up quotes on matching cover, excess and add-ons.
- Turn off automatic renewal if you plan to switch.
Our guide to ways to bring your premium down covers the changes that can cut the price. If you feel your insurer has treated you unfairly, complain to it first. It has up to 8 weeks for most complaints, and then you can go to the Financial Ombudsman Service.
Why is my car insurance going up every year?
It does not always rise. ABI figures quoted in the Taskforce report show the average premium paid was £551 in July to September 2025, lower than a year earlier. Repeated rises often point to a new address, car, driver or reported incident.
Can I refuse my renewal price?
Yes. From 1 January 2022, the FCA required insurers to give most customers simpler ways to stop automatic renewal. Turn it off or tell your insurer before the renewal date. Have new cover start the day the old policy ends, so you are never uninsured.
How much is average car insurance in the UK?
The ABI says the average premium paid was £562 in July to September 2026. That figure is based on prices customers actually paid, and your own quote depends on your age, car, postcode and history.
Does where I live change my car insurance price?
It can. Accident, theft and claims rates differ between areas, and insurers take your postcode into account. Give the address where you park at night, and tell your insurer if you move.
Do uninsured drivers push up my premium?
Indirectly, yes. The Motor Insurers’ Bureau compensates victims of uninsured and hit-and-run drivers. It is funded by a levy on all motor insurers, which the Taskforce report says is passed on in premiums. Claims costs involving uninsured drivers rose around 37% between 2019 and 2024.
Does tax add to the cost of car insurance?
Yes. Insurance Premium Tax is charged at the standard rate of 12% on car insurance, according to HMRC. It is already included in the price you are quoted.
Can I ask my insurer why my price went up?
Yes. Ask what has changed on your policy, such as your details, the drivers or an incident you reported. If you feel you were treated unfairly, complain to the insurer first. You can then go to the Financial Ombudsman Service if it has not sorted it within 8 weeks.
Does a protected no claims discount stop my price rising?
No. The Financial Ombudsman says protection usually keeps your discount level after a fault claim, but the premium itself can still go up at renewal. Check the policy wording for the exact rules.
What to do next
Have your renewal letter, car registration, driver details and claims and convictions history to hand.
When you are ready, get car insurance quotes on Tiger.co.uk using a single online form. Insuring two or more cars at home? Take a look at multi-car insurance too. It is also a good moment to check whether you have breakdown cover. Cover differs between policies, so read the wording and ask the insurer if anything is unclear. Tiger.co.uk is a comparison service, not an insurer.
Fact-checked by Ian Wilson, Managing Director at Tiger.co.uk. 20+ years in price comparison; MEng, Queen’s University Belfast.