Login Menu

Do sole traders need employers’ liability insurance?

FacebookTwitterPinterestWhatsappEmail
A UK self-employed plasterer in an orange work top on a house job briefing a younger helper who is mixing plaster

Not if you work entirely on your own. The legal duty starts the day you take someone on as an employee, unless they are close family. From then you need at least £5 million of cover from an authorised insurer (GOV.UK).

The harder part is deciding whether a helper is an employee at all. HSE judges that by how the job is actually run, so a “freelance” label or a cash payment does not settle it (HSE guide HSE40). Your business structure matters too, because the family exemption ends once you form a company.

Do you need it if you work completely alone?

No. With no one working for you, there is nobody to insure. Northern Ireland agrees: a business that is not a limited company is exempt when its owner is the only employee (nibusinessinfo.co.uk).

Claims from customers or passers-by are a separate matter. Those fall under public liability cover, which is optional in law.

Is your subcontractor or helper really your employee?

It depends on how the work is really arranged. HSE says neither the name of the contract nor the person’s tax position decides it (HSE40). Work through these questions for each person, one at a time:

  1. Does anyone besides you work in the business? If not, there is no duty.
  2. Are they on an apprenticeship? If so, treat them as an employee. HSE names apprenticeship contracts alongside contracts of service.
  3. Are they running their own business? Someone who prices the job, brings their own kit and works for other customers is probably not yours to insure.
  4. Or do you call the shots? If you set their hours and methods and hand them your tools, plan on them counting as your employee.
  5. Is every employee close family, and are you still unincorporated? If both are true, the family exemption may apply. If not, arrange cover before their first shift.

For HSE’s full list of signs, see our guide to whether public liability covers employees.

Does paying someone under CIS make them self-employed?

Not for this cover. The Construction Industry Scheme is a tax arrangement, and HSE says tax status is not the test (HSE40).

GOV.UK goes further for builders. A CIS contractor must check whether the person should be employed instead, and may get a penalty if they should be (GOV.UK CIS guide). HMRC’s employment status tool gives its view for tax only, so treat it as one clue.

Which family helpers fall outside the exemption?

Anyone who is not on GOV.UK’s close-family list. That list covers spouses and civil partners, parents, grandparents, children, grandchildren, brothers and sisters. It also includes step-parents, stepchildren and half-siblings (GOV.UK).

These family helpers are not on it, so they count like any other employee:

  • nephews, nieces and cousins
  • aunts and uncles
  • in-laws, such as a son-in-law or a mother-in-law
  • a stepbrother or stepsister
  • a partner you are not married to or in a civil partnership with

The exemption also needs every employee to be close family (HSE40). Take on one person from the list above and it no longer applies to the business.

How does your business structure change the answer?

The same helper can need cover under one set-up and not another. Where a row says to ask the insurer, the GOV.UK and HSE guidance gives no clear answer.

How you tradeWho works in itEmployers’ liability needed?
Sole traderOnly youNo
Sole traderYou plus close relatives only, such as a son or sisterNo, the family exemption applies
Sole traderYou plus a nephew, friend or any non-relativeYes, from their first day
PartnershipThe partners only, no staffUsually no, as partners are co-owners
PartnershipPartners plus relatives on the payrollAsk the insurer
Limited companyYou as the sole employee, with half the shares or moreNo, this is exempt
Limited companyYou as the sole employee, with under half the sharesYes
Limited companyYou plus your husband, wife or another relativeYes, the family exemption ends

The company rows catch people out. HSE limits the family exemption to businesses that are not limited companies (HSE40). Put cover in place for the day the new company first employs anyone, not the day the paperwork is finished.

Worked example: an electrician who incorporates

Gareth is a self-employed electrician in Swansea. His wife, Sian, does his invoicing and is paid through his payroll. She is his only employee, and a wife is on GOV.UK’s close-family list, so while he trades as a sole trader he needs no employers’ liability.

Gareth then forms a limited company. He and Sian each hold half the shares and both draw a salary. From then on the company employs two people. The family exemption no longer applies, and the owner-only exemption needs a single employee. So the company needs at least £5 million of cover from the day it first employs them.

If Sian left the payroll but kept her shares, Gareth would be the sole employee with 50%, which meets the owner-only exemption. With Gareth on 40%, it would not.

What changes when you register as an employer?

PAYE registration covers tax, not insurance. GOV.UK’s steps for a first-time employer list PAYE registration and employers’ liability as separate jobs (GOV.UK).

HMRC says you must register before the first payday, and no more than two months before you start paying people (GOV.UK). The insurance duty does not wait for that. It starts when you become an employer, so arrange cover for the first working day.

Construction contractors also register as employers when they use CIS subcontractors. That does not make the subcontractors employees.

Do seasonal or overseas helpers need cover?

Usually, if they work as your employees. HSE says the contract can be spoken, written or implied, so casual help agreed by phone still counts (HSE40).

Where someone is based matters too. The Act covers employees normally based in England, Scotland or Wales, including offshore installations. Someone normally based abroad needs cover once they spend more than 14 days in a row in Great Britain, according to HSE. That can catch a picker who comes over for the harvest.

Staff based in Northern Ireland fall under its own law, enforced by HSENI (nibusinessinfo.co.uk). Our employers’ liability page sets out the minimum cover and the fines.

Before you take on your first helper

  • Decide how you will trade, as only unincorporated businesses get the family exemption
  • Check each relative against the close-family list, including in-laws and an unmarried partner
  • If you are about to incorporate, set the cover start date to the company’s first working day
  • Tell the insurer about every role, including relatives, CIS subcontractors and cash-in-hand help

Do I need employers’ liability insurance as a sole trader with no staff?

No. GOV.UK ties the duty to becoming an employer. Until someone works for you under a contract of service or apprenticeship, there is no one the Act requires you to insure.

Does my unmarried partner count as close family?

No. GOV.UK’s close-family list names husbands, wives and civil partners, but not a partner you live with without marrying. If they work for you as an employee, you need cover.

Do I need employers’ liability for a subcontractor paid under CIS?

Possibly. CIS deductions are a tax arrangement, and HSE says tax status does not decide the question. If you control their hours and methods and supply the tools, tell your insurer.

Do I need employers’ liability for an apprentice?

Yes, unless an exemption such as the close-family one applies. HSE says the Act covers people employed under a contract of apprenticeship, and GOV.UK describes apprentices as employees earning a wage.

Does the duty apply in a partnership?

Not to the partners themselves, usually. GOV.UK says partners share responsibility for the business and each pays tax on their share of the profits. Once the partnership employs staff, it needs cover.

Do I need cover before I register for PAYE?

Yes, if you already employ someone. GOV.UK treats PAYE registration and employers’ liability as separate steps, and the insurance duty starts as soon as you become an employer.

Do I need cover for a worker who normally lives abroad?

HSE says someone normally based abroad needs cover once they spend more than 14 days in a row in Great Britain. Shorter visits may fall outside the Act, so check with your insurer.

Do I need it for a cleaner at my home?

HSE says you probably will not for a cleaner or gardener who also works for other households. Someone who works only for you may need cover, so check with an insurer before relying on that.

Does it matter that my helper is under 18?

No. Age is not one of the exemptions in GOV.UK or HSE guidance, so a young helper working as your employee needs cover. Tell the insurer their age and tasks.

What to do next

If you are about to take someone on, you can get employers’ liability quotes on Tiger.co.uk and compare providers’ prices. Cover and wording vary, so check the limit and any conditions before you buy.

If you sell know-how or design work, professional indemnity is worth a look. For the covers the law makes compulsory, read our guide on whether your business needs insurance, or browse the business insurance hub on Tiger.co.uk.

Fact-checked by Ian Wilson, Managing Director at Tiger.co.uk. 20+ years in price comparison; MEng, Queen’s University Belfast.

Click to access the login or register cheese